• Home >
  • Buy >
  • Star Wars - Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace (DVD 2004) >
  • Search results

Star Wars - Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace (DVD 2004)

Top Reviews
  Every Saga has a Beginning ... !!!!!!!!
Review created: 10/09/07
4 of 7 people found this review helpful.

Like young Anakin's future the success of The Phantom Menace is clouded !!!!!

Having run an eBay community group for Star Wars for many months the subject of the Star Wars Episode 1 has often come up .....

Is Jar Jar Binks the most despised SW character ever ?????? Possibly yes !!!!!!
What on Earth happened in the design department during the creation of 'Yoda' ?????
Jake Lloyd ?????
The whole podrace to get parts for a spaceship to introduce threepio to link to tatooine plot tangent !!!!!!!!!!
The voices of the battle droids !!!!!!!!!
Midichlorians ??????????????
YOU GET THE IDEA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

But then there are the many positive aspects of the film ...... Maul, Qui Gon Jinn, the Duel of the Fates, the battles, the locations ...... !!!!!!

For childhood fans of the Original Trilogy, the years of waiting had possibly led to too much expectation ...... but on the flipside, didn't Lucas owe these fans something much better ????????

As one friend of mine said recently , as long as it's Star Wars I would have been happy with anything !!!!!!!!!

The film isn't a failure but in trying to set up the storyline for Episodes 2 and 3 it often over explains ........ Maul's screen time is criminally reduced when the podrace just goes on and on !!!!! And although Lucas delivers SFX and the movie industry is in his debt ...... is there too much over reliance on CGI ?????

Other "artistic" aspects of the film are worryingly obvious ... the Yoda puppet from 1980's Empire Strikes Back is more lifelike than the Yoda that appears 1999's Episode 1 ... but in Episode 2 the CGI delivers a new improved Yoda ?????

Overall, Episode 1 serves as a vehicle to introduce the key players, the plot, the politics, the locations and the galaxy in which the Old Republic spoken about by Old Ben in 1977 still exist !!!

...... we all knew how the story ends and our frustrations about how the saga actually begins must be balanced by the fact that during Episode 2 and 3 the sense of Star Wars returns !!!!!!!

Episode 1 can't be ignored but in an online poll I ran, and others I have seen ... The Phantom Menace always comes bottom !!!!!!!

and this was the film that countless 30 plus year old's (like myself) had waited years for ..... the teaser trailers, the posters, the hype .... in 1983 (after seeing Return Of The Jedi) I knew that one day Episodes 1,2 and 3 would be made ..... Episode 1 simply failed to live up to the standard of the Original Trilogy
!!!!!

Thankfully , the prequels improved ......


Review ID: 10000000004377779
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  An excellent start to the series , but for kids !!
Review created: 22/06/06
by:
6 of 13 people found this review helpful.

As someone who watched the prequal trilogy soon after watching the original, I feel I can give a fairer opinion on the films than certain other fans, and I have to say that The Phantom Menace was a DVD worth buying.

The Storyline, In my Opinion, was fairly good, better once you see episodes 2 and 3, with some fantastic Lightsabre Duals and action scenes. The acting by Jake Lloyd could have been better in most places, but Ray Park's portrayal of Darth Maul was brilliant, and although there has been accusations of 'wooden acting' I think all the actors played their parts fairly well.

One major reason This Film didn't get 5 from me was Jar-Jar Binks. Fair enough, it was a good Idea to feature a character like this, but the ammount of Idiocy coming from him every 15 seconds is simply too much. I don't think anyone would have minded Jar-Jar if Lucas had simply featured less scenes with him messing about (sometimes totally unnecessarily), but like I say, he was shown far too often doing something stupid, which, in some cases, ruins the films atmosphere.

All in all, I think this is a great addition to the Star Wars Saga, and an enjoyable Sci-Fi film for kids and Adults, the DVD has great special features, and is well worth the price.


Review ID: 10000000001226248
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
Sort by:
Reviews
  wibble wibble wibble
Review created: 12/07/08
by:

wibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibblewibble wibble wibble


Review ID: 10000000007955127
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars - Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace (DVD 2004)
Review created: 10/06/08
by:

My 7 year old son loves Star Wars and wanted the first episodes. I did tell him that these weren't the first ones, 4, 5 and 6 were, but he just looked at me as though I was daft :) The films have linked into the original stories really well and to my son the story is seamless. May the force be with you :)


Review ID: 10000000007529938
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  TPM - Bashed for long enough?
Review created: 06/06/08

Badly criticized by ..... critics who love to overintellectualize a film - you might find this worth watching if you already are a Star Wars fan. People say GL was saving the best for later (later prequel episodes) and its true that there are some juvenile sequences in the movie. But the backstory of Sidious pulling the strings to push the current Supreme Chancellor out of the picture as a devious prelude to his future schemes is what MAKES this movie. Only Star Wars fans can think something of this - even if you're not so keen. the story is THERE. The pacing is bad, but there are moments in this film that prove to be pure eye candy. The end duel with Darth Maul vs. Obi Wan and Qui Gon Jinn is one of the best fight scenes ever put on film despite this movie's imperfections. I rate this film an 8 out of 10. I certainly wish that this review is justified. Anyways, this could be a see and see again amongst Star Wars fans --- with fastforwards that is. (What I said about the pacing)


Review ID: 10000000007450619
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  star wars
Review created: 25/05/08
by:

i bought this for my 6 year old son as he got interested in star wars by playing the lego version on his playstation. he himself thinks it is brillant and has nearly all of them except the last one at the moment.

the story line is brillant and you can get behind the characters and especially watching the banter between c3-po and r2-d2 is excellant with the little quirkies they come out with. i would recommend it for anyone. i myself did find it hard to watch at first since the first one which came out was episode 4 new hope which i watched when i was a kid then when that triology ended he then brought out 1/2/3 afterwards so it was a bit hard to get back into it since i knew what was happening in the future


Review ID: 10000000007276942
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  fun film
Review created: 10/05/08
by:

great fun film, makes me a 12 year old again. the end lightsabre battle is nothing short of amazing.


Review ID: 10000000007108597
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars Phantom Menace
Review created: 01/05/08
by:

I bought it because I also bought the dual darth maul lightsaber and wanted to see it in action in the actual film.

I love darth maul in it but absolutly hate Jar Jar Binks, film would have been so much better without him IMO.


Review ID: 10000000006918505
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Or...Star Wars: The Phantom Plot
Review created: 04/04/08
by:

Oh dear. As a 'child of Star Wars', I was so looking forward to the return of George Lucas as director of his creation. Three words describe the early exchanges of this film; awful, awful, awful. The basic premise is ropey at best and the dialogue is largely non-existent. This hideousness masks a manful attempt by Liam Neeson, who plays Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn, to pull the film up from on it's backside and Ewan MacGregor's first stab at Obi-Wan Kenobi, where he might have tried less to 'be' Alec Guinness and could easily have succeeded in a masterful portrayal.

The live action actors are not the worst thing about this film, enter Jar Jar Binks - I still get flashbacks about this pitiful inclusion, clearly designed to ensnare a younger audience and guarantee additional merchandising revenue.

Enough griping, there are lots of things that will keep me coming back to this despite the flaws:
- some superb CGI, notably the pod race
- the scenes on Tattooine which render this opener quintessentially Star Wars
- the introduction of Darth Maul, complete with double-ended lightsaber
- the closing two-on-one lightsaber duel between the two Jedi and the aforementioned Maul
- hey, it IS Star Wars....

As much as I'd like to totally pan this, the eight year-old who sat and gasped at the sight of a Star Destroyer cruising overhead in the late 70's just wouldn't let me. Only just passes muster though.


Review ID: 10000000006497928
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
Review created: 04/04/08
by:

If like me your a big Sci-Fi nut then this is deffinately the start of the ultimate series for you. In the first witness the rise of the trade federation and over the next few episodes watch it turn into the Evil Empire.

It's an excellent film with some great sound affects and acting well recommended.


Review ID: 10000000006491314
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars - Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace
Review created: 29/03/08

I am a great fan of all the star wars films. The imagery, plot and special effects make star wars classic films that i enjoy watching from time to time, on cold rainy days when it is better to stay indoors, warm and enchanted with the magical fantasy films of Star Wars.


Review ID: 10000000006379273
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  star wars episode 1-the phantom menace
Review created: 24/02/08(updated 11/04/08)
by:

i had the vhs,but decided to get the dvd,it didnt dissapoint..stars wars is one of those programmes that hooks you all your life,the characters are such lifelike,the action is wonderful..
i rate this dvd and the saga first class...


Review ID: 10000000005786448
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  great film ,must seen film
Review created: 04/02/08
by:

great film special effects are great brill director.love the acting from the young stars .brillo fim


Review ID: 10000000005389888
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars: Episode 1- The Phantom Menace
Review created: 30/01/08
by:

Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace is the perfect showcase for the incredible detail and breathtaking scope of George Lucas. See how the Star Wars story started in The Phantom menace. DVD packed with hours of additional material. A must have.


Review ID: 10000000005283133
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  star wars the phantom menace
Review created: 27/01/08

very good condition and sent out really quick.was cheaper than buying from shop as they were 20 pounds a dvd.thank you


Review ID: 10000000005241435
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  star wars always the best
Review created: 27/01/08
by:

The phantom menace the first of the sixlogy.Biliand film was the only that missing for my collection. Fantastic efe and very good acting.Adventure and gomedy the same time. Best film.


Review ID: 10000000005234218
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  How to get an iPhone, Wii, PS3 or 360 for nothing!
Review created: 19/01/08
by:

The Free iPhone Guide


To get yourself a free iPhone all you have to do is follow the 3 easy steps:

Step 1 : Sign up for a free iPhone
Sign up at the link below to get your free iPhone. We recommend this free iPhone site because it's been TRIED and TESTED to work.

http://Gifts.real-incentives.com/2992 (copy and paste into browser)

You can choose other prizes like free consoles from this site too! Make sure you use a real email address. Use your real details when you sign up so that the company knows where to send your iPhone! Remember that they have been proven legitimate, so will send you your free iPhone if you do everything legitimately!

Step 2 : Try an advertiser's offer
Basically all you need to do in this step is complete one of the offers, this is where the freebie site make their money, if you complete an offer then the freebie site will recieve commission for it. So if you complete Coral which will only cost you £5 to complete, the freebie site gets £25 from Coral. The two best offers are Lovefilm Free DVD rental (rent two DVD's, keep them for about 2 days, send them back and then cancel the trial) and Coral (bet £5 on a sport). I would reccommend you do Coral as it credits in an hour and is really simple to do, Lovefilm however can become complicated and takes up to 2 weeks to credit! You can also try one of the other offers, most are gambling offers. Don't skip this step! You must complete this step to get your free iPhone!

Step 3 : Refer some friends
This part is a lot easier than it seems, especially now with free iPhone sites getting so popular. There's lots of people online who want a free iPhone too, so start referring them! You only need to get a few signups before you'll be finished. You can ask your friends or your online buddies. I already got a free PS3, Wii, and XBOX Elite without even having to ask my friends for help - there's lots of people online who want a free iPhone like you! One of the easiest ways to get a referral is to do a favour for a friend and ask them to sign up in return. That way, you both can get a free iPhone!

Basic rules
Don't break these rules! This is the only reason that you won't get your free iPhone, so make sure you follow these rules!

- One account per household - don't use a public computer to sign up!
- Use real information - this is a proven legitimate site and they will not give out your information.
- Only complete each offer once! You cannot complete the same offer again, even for different freebies.
- Don't try to cheat the system. This site has been proven legitimate, and they will catch you if you try to cheat. If you do everything legitimately, by following this guide, you will get a free iPhone!

Thats all, just follow my guide and you will have your free iPhone in no time.

Thank you.


Review ID: 10000000005158263
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  how to get a Wii, iPhone, PS3, 360 for nothing
Review created: 06/01/08
by:

The Free iPhone Guide


To get yourself a free iPhone all you have to do is follow the 3 easy steps:

Step 1 : Sign up for a free iPhone
Sign up at the link below to get your free iPhone. We recommend this free iPhone site because it's been TRIED and TESTED to work. Need more info or help?

http://Gifts.real-incentives.com/2992 (copy and paste into browser)

You can choose other prizes like free consoles from this site too! Make sure you use a real email address. Use your real details when you sign up so that the company knows where to send your iPhone! Remember that they have been proven legitimate, so will send you your free iPhone if you do everything legitimately!

Step 2 : Try an advertiser's offer
Basically all you need to do in this step is complete one of the offers, this is where the freebie site make their money, if you complete an offer then the freebie site will recieve commission for it. So if you complete Coral which will only cost you £5 to complete, the freebie site gets ��25 from Coral. The two best offers are Lovefilm Free DVD rental (rent two DVD's, keep them for about 2 days, send them back and then cancel the trial) and Coral (bet £5 on a sport). I would reccommend you do Coral as it credits in an hour and is really simple to do, Lovefilm however can become complicated and takes up to 2 weeks to credit! You can also try one of the other offers, most are gambling offers. Don't skip this step! You must complete this step to get your free iPhone!

Step 3 : Refer some friends
This part is a lot easier than it seems, especially now with free iPhone sites getting so popular. There's lots of people online who want a free iPhone too, so start referring them! You only need to get a few signups before you'll be finished. You can ask your friends or your online buddies. I already got a free PS3, Wii, and XBOX Elite without even having to ask my friends for help - there's lots of people online who want a free iPhone like you! One of the easiest ways to get a referral is to do a favour for a friend and ask them to sign up in return. That way, you both can get a free iPhone!

Basic rules
Don't break these rules! This is the only reason that you won't get your free iPhone, so make sure you follow these rules!

- One account per household - don't use a public computer to sign up!
- Use real information - this is a proven legitimate site and they will not give out your information.
- Only complete each offer once! You cannot complete the same offer again, even for different freebies.
- Don't try to cheat the system. This site has been proven legitimate, and they will catch you if you try to cheat. If you do everything legitimately, by following this guide, you will get a free iPhone!

Thats all, just follow my guide and you will have your free iPhone in no time.

Thank you.


Review ID: 10000000005006916
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
Review created: 16/12/07
by:

The dvd was great, the postage was great, the contact was good, everything was brilliant.the dvd worked perfectly and even came with 2 discs. it had great defination.


Review ID: 10000000004868551
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  £5 ipods and consoles!
Review created: 12/12/07
by:
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Are you looking to find an iPod Touch, nano or a console for £5?? then visit:

http://gifts.real-incentives.com/2992 (copy and paste URL into browser)

All you have to follow to get your £5 gift are 3 easy steps:

1. Sign up to the site above. (fill in your details eg. name, country).

2. Complete an offer - For UK residents the best offer to do is Coral, all you have to do is bet £5 on a sport and thats it! For US residents you can do the STAMPS 30 day free trial, this is totally free. If you dont like their service then just cancel your subscription. Your offer will STILL show as complete.

3. Refer family and/or friends - just get friends and family to complete an offer and deposit £5.

Thats all! Its as easy as that! You'll have an iPod worth up to £200 for only £5! So give it a try, you 've got nothing to lose.


Review ID: 10000000004851923
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Wanted to see this episode
Review created: 09/09/07
by:

I liked the film because I like all things Star Wars. The story was brilliant and I liked all the characters in it. The chase scene was very good. It is a good family film and well woth watching. My young son tells me it is marvelous!!!


Review ID: 10000000004368043
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars episode 1 The Phantom Menace
Review created: 08/09/07
by:

A great film from George Lucas, here we see the beginning of this epic saga when Anakin is a young boy found by Qui-Gon Jinn and his apprentice Obi-Wan Kenobi on a distan planet called Tatooine. Here Anakin is a slave...but not for long. IT is a great movie, enjoyable like all the rest, it has its small laughs with R2D2 and C3P0 as well as all out action in duel laser battles and an awesome pod race showdown. Definitely one DVD you mus add to ur collection, add the whole lot, like i did.
Enjoy


Review ID: 10000000004348725
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Star Wars
Review created: 01/08/07(updated 01/08/07)
by:

After bringing up a son who loved Star Wars, his son, my Grandson, is now re-living the Star Wars era.
He is thoroughly enjoying the films, and will be collecting them all if he has his way. Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace is the first of his collection of star wars films.
This film was in great condition, and I have loved seeing my young grandson's enjoyment of it.


Review ID: 10000000004079245
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  phatom menace starwars dvd
Review created: 09/07/07
by:

another film bought for my son to add to his collection of one of his favourite films. to put in the portable dvd player he now has. others in his family arent so keen so he can listen with his head phones,


Review ID: 10000000003983579
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  The Phantom Menace
Review created: 08/07/07

Episode 1 was a great film (Yes, I know that Jarjar wasn't George Lucas's greatest moment).

If you have Dolby 5.1 surround sound - the podrace is amazing!

And the final duel between Qui-gon, Obi-wan and darth Maul is just brilliant.


Review ID: 10000000003962573
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Excellent Product
Review created: 07/07/07
by:

A 2 Disc limited edition DVD a lot cheaper than in the Big shops.
I bought this for my son to complete his collection of Star Wars films.
Excellent new condition and a very good fast service from the seller.
Would buy other Dvds etc from this guy.


Review ID: 10000000003952607
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
 
Page 1 of 3Previous 1 | 2 | 3 NextGo to page

About eBay | Announcements | Safety Centre | Partner Centre | VeRO Protecting IP | Policies | Feedback Forum | Site Map | Help
Copyright © 1995-2008 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the eBay User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
eBay official time
Save this search
Name this searchPlease enter a name for your search.Replace an existing search?
Replace this search
Please select a search to replace.
Cancel