
A good album, but a worrying downward turn

As always, the Foo Fighters delivered a good solid album of post-grunge hard rock. It features their usual range of material, with their hard-hitting rhythms and great sound throughout, and it feels very well produced.
That's the problem though. This album may be technically accomplished, and the band may play more tightly than ever before, but the rough, raw edge, and brutal delivery that made much of their earlier material so powerful is missing. And that power is needed more on this album than on any of the previous releases, because sadly the songs are not as good as I had come to expect from them. Of course there are some great tracks here, but overall it seems a bit flat and tired, even formulaic. Every Foo Fighters album delivers musical ups and downs, but on "One by One" the highs aren't high enough, and there are far too many lows. There are very few of the instantly memorable themes that previous releases gave us.
On the positive side, the band plays as a tight cohesive musical unit on this album, and the guitar, and especially the drums sound superbly focused and impressive. There are perhaps 3 or 4 great tracks on the album. "All My Life" is a brilliant opener, full of snarling, chopped guitar and machine-gun drummimg, with a surprisingly catchy melody line, and tortured lyrics - one of their best ever. "Times Like These" is a impressive track which builds from a restrained but interesting opening to a much heavier (and much more pleasing) climax. "Have It All" is an intense rhythm workout, where the group flexes it's muscles to maximum effect, and once again comes to a very satisfying conclusion, with clashing cymbals and overdriven power chords. "Burn Away" features one of the best guitar intros ever, but doesn't quite hit the mark overall.
This album is a very good one, and there are some really excellent tracks here, but it is perhaps the weakest of their albums overall. Try "In Your Honour", their latest and best, to really hear what makes the Foo Fighters such a great group.
Review ID: 10000000002574741

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.