
Battlestar Galactica - Reimagined
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
In the same way that Star Wars fans felt a mix of excitement and trepidation prior to the three prequels (which produced a wide variety of opinion, much of it negative until Episode 3) the same generation of fans probably enjoyed the original Battlestar Galactica and were equally fearful of the dreaded re-imagining of the saga, given that the TV industry often tries to cash in and re-hash an old show rather than update and (attempt to) improve the original.
While it's easy to criticise the many faults of the original show (repetitive special effects/soap opera storylines/some downright awful acting at times) there can be no doubt that no Sci-Fi TV show looked or sounded as good as Battlestar Galactica did, and the underlying story was inspired and somehow believable. In terms of design, it was amazing, with the Colonial Viper being my childhood spacecraft of choice, even above an X-Wing fighter. The special effects were largely excellent (John Dykstra worked on Star Wars, after all) and my Sunday afternoons in the early 1980's were made or broken by Battlestar Galactica. Surely any update would only ever be a souped up copycat version of the original? Not so here...
Battlestar Galactica - The Mini Series, as an homage to it's precursor, could be considered a resounding success, but this is much more than a mere re-make; while the ultimate endgame remains the same - finding the 13th Colony that escaped to Earth - this is a far deeper, more complex and compelling story, and it's probably not for kids either. Visually, TV doesn't get any better than this and the cast are convincing not only in their sincerity (contextually speaking) but as characters in their own right. Moreoever, the re-imagining of the Cylons, some of whom look and sound like humans, is both interesting and compelling. Where the all-new Galactica really stands up, however, is in demonstrating the fragility of human life and you never feel, once, that there's going to be a happy ending...
It also introduces a far more political angle to the franchise which will undoubtedly be a plot driver in later episodes. The lead characters have gravitas, the good guys are not all completely good and the bad guys are not completely bad...this deliciously grey area makes for compelling viewing.
CGI is an important part of the all new Battlestar Galactica, but it's used here to drive the story forward, not for cosmetic visceral effect and the familiarity it's retained to the original series is both pleasing and heart-warming. That the Galactica here is portrayed as something of a dinosaur is both essential to the story and also heart-warming, especially to fans of the original series.
My only disappointment is that the original music hasn't been retained (although it's used once at the Galactica's "decommissioning ceremony") but given the more sombre mood of Galactica circa 2004, the original epic score would seem far too cheery and upbeat.
Having bought this DVD I immeddiately sought out the 3 series that followed, having missed it the first time around and i've not been disappointed. As an opening to this all-new Galactica saga, however, this is pretty much unmissable viewing, and I for one heartily recommend it.
Review ID: 10000000005417833

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.